The Making of Peter Bogdanovich, in His Own Words

2026-11-17T21:49:03.709Z

When Peter Bogdanovich died, in 2022, at the age of eighty-two, I commemorated his achievements, both as director and as cinephile, with special attention to activities that, though historically crucial, were somewhat under the radar. From 1961 to 1963, in his early twenties, he organized three retrospectives at MOMA, of the films of Orson Welles, Howard Hawks, and Alfred Hitchcock. These served as auteurist coming-out parties, proof that—as Bogdanovich detailed in accompanying monographs—these bodies of work are thematically and stylistically coherent. Meanwhile, throughout the decade, he interviewed and befriended many of the leading directors of classic Hollywood, and wrote a batch of articles and books that displayed the living concept of the auteur—a filmmaker who, whether working in the mainstream of the industry or as an independent, displayed a comprehensive and distinctive artistry akin to that of a book’s author or of an artist in any other medium. And then he became one himself.

The idea of the aesthetic primacy of directors working in the studio system has long aroused controversy. The great achievement of some young French critics of the nineteen-fifties was to recognize the wide-ranging originality and personality of hitherto underacknowledged Hollywood studio directors. When these critics then became world-famous directors themselves—the prime figures of the French New Wave—their films proved the fruitfulness of their taste and their conceptual framework. In the U.S., by contrast, there was a division of labor. The idea of the Hollywood auteur was imported, in the early nineteen-sixties, largely by critics who were not filmmakers themselves—Andrew Sarris, at the Village Voice, and Eugene Archer, at the Times. But it was Bogdanovich who provided the concept’s bridge into filmmaking, and into the very heart of Hollywood.

In the midst of these labors, Bogdanovich was also engaged in yet another effort, a private one, which is only now coming to light. From 1965 to 1971, he wrote thousands of pages of diary entries. Decades later, he made plans to publish them, adding an introduction, a conclusion, and extensive interstitial commentaries and annotations. He died before he could complete the project, but the result, “But What I Really Want to Do Is Direct” (Harper), has now been released, edited by the film historian Sam Wasson, whom Bogdanovich recruited for guidance, and who ultimately shepherded the tome to publication. The book tells—in an unusual format—the extraordinary personal story of Bogdanovich’s many achievements in the nineteen-sixties and the early seventies, from his advocacy for great elder directors to his own rise to directorial eminence.

“But What I Really Want to Do Is Direct” is the story of an aesthetic education and a sentimental one; it’s a work of history and a real-time bildungsroman. Six main story lines emerge: Bogdanovich’s directorial career, his journalistic career, his personal relationships with directors and actors, his obsessive movie viewing, his relationships with his parents, and his relationship with his wife at the time, Polly Platt, who was his collaborator in all of his creative ventures in this period. In the course of the book, Platt and Bogdanovich have two children together and are driven apart—by Bogdanovich’s affair with the actress Cybill Shepherd, who made her début in his second film, “The Last Picture Show.” The confessional intimacy of the diary, and its candor about sex (amplified in Bogdanovich’s retrospective commentaries), meshes with the narrative of a crucial moment in Hollywood history. These were the years in which the generational change that was shaking the country at large challenged the industry’s boundaries and verities (along with its profits) and brought about enduring changes in the business and the art—changes in which Bogdanovich played a major role.

To make sense of it, a bit of backstory: Bogdanovich was born in 1939 and raised on the Upper West Side in a family of bohemian poverty. His father, Borislav, was a Serbian-born artist whose work didn’t sell much; his mother, née Herma Robinson, was Vienna-born and artistically cultivated, and kept the family afloat by working in her father’s import-export business. Together, they inculcated young Peter with their own passion for movies. From the time he was twelve, in 1952, until February, 1971—a terminus mentioned in the diaries—he kept index cards for every movie he’d seen. (Some of them are reproduced in the book.) From the time he saw “Citizen Kane,” he wanted to direct movies, but his first step was as a precocious child of the theatre—an acting student of Stella Adler’s at sixteen, an American Shakespeare Festival summer-stock actor, an acclaimed Off Broadway director at twenty. Meanwhile, he gained a foothold in the city’s movie scene, writing program notes for the New Yorker Theatre, a seminal Upper West Side repertory cinema (and no relation to this magazine).

He also talked his way into securing a letter of introduction from the editor of Harper’s, which, during a visit Bogdanovich paid to Hollywood in 1961, helped him to interview such notables as Hitchcock, Walt Disney, Billy Wilder, Angie Dickinson, and Jack Lemmon. That year, as artistic director for a new theatre company, he met Platt, who was working as a production designer, and they married the next year. Thanks to a chance conversation she had with Esquire’s editor, Harold Hayes, Bogdanovich was commissioned to profile Jerry Lewis, the first of many articles he wrote for the magazine. When Bogdanovich told the innovative comedy director Frank Tashlin that what he really wanted to do was direct, Tashlin exhorted him to move to where movies were made. In the summer of 1964, Bogdanovich and Platt drove from New York to Los Angeles.

In other words, Bogdanovich was no ordinary movie nerd: he was a worldly nerd with a fine human touch, a sharp wit, a winning personality, and an unflagging sense of his own destiny. His diaries catch a journalistic career already in progress and a movie career that was sparked by his journalism. With his mighty fund of knowledge and his keen taste and judgment, he talked and noodged and charmed and impressed his way into the film business. By way of his relationships with his elders, the great directors of classic Hollywood, he powered his way into the art of cinema.

In the first diary entry, from June 3, 1965, Bogdanovich notes that it was Platt’s idea for the two of them to keep diaries, and that she shoplifted his journal for him. The couple was poor, living, per Bogdanovich, “hand to mouth,” and Platt’s thefts for them included food: “Had a splendid supper of stolen roast beef (is it possible that it actually tastes better stolen—if so, Polly is the best cook around).” That first entry also establishes the couple’s movie-viewing habits. That day, they watched two movies together: John M. Stahl’s 1943 comedy “Holy Matrimony”—“in bed this morning,” meaning, on television—and, that evening, in a theatre, a new release, “The Collector,” directed by William Wyler. Bogdanovich comments, “Every week, like clockwork, I would get the new issue of TV Guide and go through the list of scheduled films, checking off the ones I needed to watch; I would refer to my ‘Films-to-See’ list to confirm titles.” The obsessive practice required early-morning awakenings and late-night vigils. When TV didn’t come through with his desired films, he had another trick up his sleeve: he often asked directors he’d interviewed to get studios where they worked to screen classics for him. For instance, by mid-1965, Bogdanovich writes, Jerry Lewis had “already made it possible for me to run eighty-two features at the studio—absorbing the costs into his own production company.” In 1965, Bogdanovich saw five hundred and forty-nine films. By mid-1965, Bogdanovich also had got a foot in the door, thanks to an encounter, at a screening of Jacques Demy’s “Bay of Angels,” with the producer and director Roger Corman.

A specialist in low-budget genre films, Corman invited Bogdanovich to send story ideas, and soon hired Bogdanovich to work on a movie that he was directing, “The Wild Angels,” a motorcycle-gang drama based on the Hells Angels. Bogdanovich was nominally an assistant but, in practice, he became a creative factotum: he served unofficially as second-unit director, did extensive rewrites, and was present on the set to make script changes on the fly and to function as a sort of shadow director. (After the shoot was done, he also did some of the editing.) Released in 1966, the movie, which had been made for just three hundred and sixty thousand dollars, took in more than six million dollars at the domestic box-office and made an instant star of Peter Fonda. It also inspired Fonda to make “Easy Rider” (which was released in 1969), one of the pivotal films of so-called New Hollywood.

This success got Bogdanovich the chance to direct his first feature, which Corman offered to produce. The film,“Targets,” was made in 1967, but no studio made an offer to release it. Bogdanovich’s response involved chutzpah of a rare purity: he was friends with two film critics—one from Variety and the other from The Hollywood Reporter—and he asked them to watch the film and review it if they liked it and ignore it if they didn’t. The ploy worked: one liked it, the other loved it, and the reviews got attention. The movie was acquired by Paramount and released, in August, 1968, to largely enthusiastic reviews. Bogdanovich was profiled in the Times. “Targets” was much admired within Hollywood, though it was rejected by Cannes and the New York Film Festival and did poorly at the box-office. Still, this succès d’estime brought no new work. (“No deal anywhere. It’s almost the end of 1968 and still nothing—very frustrating is not even the word. Very discouraging too,” Bogdanovich writes.) In 1969, while struggling to get a project of his own off the ground, he went to Rome, where Sergio Leone wanted him to direct a new spaghetti Western; he found Leone too controlling and walked away.

The diary entries related to Bogdanovich’s negotiations for his next film, “The Last Picture Show,” based on a novel of the same title by Larry McMurtry, feature his bewildered portraiture of a new breed of Hollywood potentates—the film’s producer, Bert Schneider, and his circle, which included Dennis Hopper and Jack Nicholson. Bogdanovich was their contemporary, but given his own proximity to the old guard he felt generationally remote: “They’re sort of peculiar people—I can’t see them getting old,” he wrote. The deal to make the film wasn’t sealed until June, 1970, and Bogdanovich’s journal closely tracks the ordeal of getting there: acquiring rights to the novel from a previous option-holder, working on the script with McMurtry, lining up practicalities, such as locations, before a deal is even signed. “I feel thoroughly depressed now and disheartened,” Bogdanovich writes. “I’m obviously doing too many things at once—and I’m not sure this is at all the right way to handle matters. . . . It’s an ugly world and I keep believing it isn’t.”

Bogdanovich’s frequent swings between excitement and despair reflect another noteworthy quality of the book and of Bogdanovich’s personality: his endearing, identifiable ordinariness. Throughout his diaries, he gives the sense of being a regular guy thrust into extraordinary situations—essentially, a Hitchcock character. He has a fanatical drive for success, with a very clear idea of what that success would resemble (the careers of the Hollywood filmmakers whose work he loves). At the same time, he feels like a child who could never wear the mighty mantle of his heroes, but merely touch its hem and get their benediction. He comes across as an innocent who has encountered this adult world and is both inside and outside it, taking a place within it while observing his own situation with wonder.

Part of Bogdanovich’s sense of ordinariness involved family and love. His filial piety was profound; he discusses in detail his parents’ key role in his cinematic formation, their encouragement of his artistic ventures, and the sacrifices they made for his education and cultivation—private school, summer camp, acting classes. (“They never had a lot of money, but somehow we never actually felt poor.”) By the time of these diaries, his parents were deep in debt to a moneylender and came to him for money; despite his and Platt’s own strained finances, he had trouble saying no. (At one point, he got a three-thousand-dollar advance from Corman to send them.) Platt resented these entreaties and also, Bogdanovich sensed, his close bond with his parents, something she didn’t have with hers; he spoke with his parents often and saw them as much as possible. His devotion to them, both material and emotional, became a source of marital conflict. But Platt, who died in 2011, is the heroine of this story, indispensable to Bogdanovich’s rise from local prodigy to star director.

The two were true collaborators, watching and discussing movies together, sharing in virtually every aspect of his creative activity. Platt wasn’t a movie person when they met, but, quickly absorbing that world from him, she proved to have sure, sharp judgment. She was the first editor of his articles and books, often accompanying him to visits with great filmmakers; she read scripts with and for him, went location scouting with him, took part in casting, watched cuts of his films. Through her work with Bogdanovich, Platt became the first woman to be accepted into the production designers’ union. The couple’s first child, Antonia, was born in 1967, just as Bogdanovich was completing “Targets.” Their second, Alexandra, was born in 1970, a few weeks before the shoot of “The Last Picture Show.” In his diaries, Bogdanovich writes of Platt with admiration and gratitude, acknowledging her artistry and her devotion. But one problem is hinted at in the diary, and made explicit in his commentary: he finds their marriage sexually unsatisfying.

The diary, in charting the making of “The Last Picture Show,” also tracks the development of Bogdanovich’s relationship with Shepherd in the course of the shoot. Before the affair starts, much of his account of their working relationship involved his plans for a nude scene that she didn’t want to do. Though Bogdanovich hoped she’d do it, he was prepared to use a body double. Then, at one point, he propositions her; at another, he claims she’s leading him on. When the affair begins, Platt quickly catches on, and Bogdanovich is conflicted: “Polly is being very brave and incredibly strong about the Cybill thing—which is getting a little tiresome. But now I’m getting worried that I’ll screw up the picture if I break it off.” But the affair proves to be Bogdanovich’s sexual awakening. For a brief time during the shoot, he and Shepherd stay together in a room in the Bogdanovich-Platt family home. By the time the diary ends, in May, 1971, Bogdanovich has moved out to live with Shepherd.

When “The Last Picture Show” came out, in October, 1971, it was more than a box-office hit; it was a phenomenon, hailed as a new masterwork by a new directorial hero. In 1972, Bogdanovich got two Oscar nominations, for Best Director and (with McMurtry) Best Adapted Screenplay. The film received six more nominations, including Best Picture, and it won two—for supporting performances by Cloris Leachman and Ben Johnson. The movie launched the careers of other cast members, notably Ellen Burstyn and Jeff Bridges (who were also nominated for Oscars) and the brothers Sam and Timothy Bottoms.

As Bogdanovich’s career took off, some of his most important achievements were in the realm of casting, hiring, and mentorship. Frank Marshall, a U.C.L.A. student hired as an apprentice on “Targets,” worked with Bogdanovich for about a decade, working his way up to producer, and eventually he became a producer of major films, including “Raiders of the Lost Ark,” and co-founded Amblin Entertainment (with Steven Spielberg and Kathleen Kennedy). Verna Fields, a sound editor who worked on “Targets” and whom Bogdanovich hired to edit the images on three of his films, was thus propelled to prominence and hired by George Lucas as co-editor of “American Graffiti” (for which she was nominated for an Oscar) and by Steven Spielberg as the editor of “Jaws,” for which she won an Oscar.

Even before “The Last Picture Show” was released, Bogdanovich was in huge demand, sought as director by both Steve McQueen and Barbra Streisand. Bogdanovich was delighted by the prospects they offered: “I want to go into the mainstream.” He picked Streisand, who starred in Bogdanovich’s third feature, the comedy “What’s Up, Doc?”—co-starring Ryan O’Neal and including, in her feature-film début, Madeline Kahn. Platt worked on the film as production designer; the creative partnership remained, for the time being.

Bogdanovich’s most important relationships were arguably his friendships with directors of an earlier generation. “What’s Up, Doc?” was loosely based on the classic screwball comedy “Bringing Up Baby,” by Howard Hawks, one of the great directors whom he befriended. Bogdanovich had interviewed Hawks for his 1962 MOMA monograph, stayed in touch, and forged a warm bond with him during a weeklong visit to his 1965 shoot of “El Dorado.” He also visited the set of “Rio Lobo,” which proved to be the older man’s last film, despite his many attempts to get financing for another. By the time the diaries start, Bogdanovich had already connected with many of his other heroes; his ambitions grew in step with his writing commissions, and he envisioned interview books and retrospectives of their work. Many of these filmmakers, despite their acclaim in France and in narrow American cinephile circles, had gone out of fashion and were less revered and less busy than they ought to have been. Bogdanovich’s sincerely passionate admiration was good for more than their egos: he gave them crucial publicity by writing about them seriously as artists in general-readership publications.

Thus most of the Hollywood luminaries whom Bogdanovich courted reciprocated, and over time they became central figures in his and Platt’s social lives. (May 21, 1966: “Cary Grant called to ask us to the ballgame tonight!”) The couple visited John Ford one Christmas, Howard Hawks another; they attended Ford’s Memorial Day services and a birthday party for his daughter. They were invited to the homes of Jean Renoir and King Vidor, Josef von Sternberg and Fritz Lang; they swam in Frank Tashlin’s swimming pool and dropped over to Jerry Lewis’s house to bring an anniversary gift (which they’d shoplifted). They dined with Samuel Fuller and Don Siegel and Budd Boetticher. Bogdanovich lunched with George Cukor and Otto Preminger, visited Frank Capra in Palm Springs and Leo McCarey in the hospital.

Many of these friends advised Bogdanovich on his early films. Fuller gave major guidance on the script of “Targets” and Cukor provided useful suggestions; Preminger watched a cut of it and weighed in. Ford didn’t give Bogdanovich notes; he was, rather, a life force, a cross between a spiritual adviser and a second family, with all the attending complications and conflicts. When Bogdanovich and Platt visited, Ford would be sometimes outrageous (playing dress-up), sometimes gruff, sometimes maudlin, sometimes a fountain of hearty energy and warm humor. From an artistic perspective, Bogdanovich found Hawks uniquely inspiring, an intellectual in outdoorsman’s guise, naturally stylish: “always so remarkably reasonable about everything—without malice and full of sense”; “so much in control of himself—so self-assured.” Bogdanovich often visited Hitchcock on his shoots, noting that “his self-discipline and his knowledge on a set is staggering.”

Meanwhile, Bogdanovich was something of a Swiss Army knife of critically insightful publicity and advocacy for these directors. He published interview books about Ford, Lang, and Allan Dwan, and directed a feature-length documentary about Ford. Fuller couldn’t get work in Hollywood, and borrowed money liberally from Bogdanovich whenever the younger man came into any. Hitchcock asked Bogdanovich to ghostwrite a piece for him for the London Times; Bogdanovich taught a course on Hawks’s films at U.C.L.A. He became their bridge to a generation—of both producers and audience members—who otherwise paid them little mind.

Bogdanovich forged tight connections with three of the four figures on his personal Mt. Rushmore—Ford, Hawks, and Hitchcock, who were the three signatories for his application to the Directors Guild of America. The fourth figure, Bogdanovich’s elusive ultimate get, was Orson Welles. By the time they finally connected (Saturday, August 31, 1968: “I met Orson Welles today!!”), it wasn’t entirely clear who had caught whom. Welles had recently made one of his greatest films, directing and starring as Falstaff in “Chimes at Midnight,” which was scantly released in the U.S., to insignificant business and some scathing reviews; he couldn’t get funding for a film in Hollywood. He was forthcoming and generous, though his friendliness came with a virtual demand: Welles wanted Bogdanovich to devote an interview book to him, like the one on Ford. Bogdanovich was only too happy to do it, and they agreed to split the profits. They spent much time together, professionally and socially; they recorded many interviews between 1969 and 1972, and Bogdanovich edited the transcripts obsessively, cutting into work on his own films to do so. But, later in the decade, when Welles signed a deal to write a memoir, the project was mothballed. (Welles’s book was never completed, and Bogdanovich’s book wasn’t published until 1992, seven years after Welles’s death, as “This Is Orson Welles,” edited by Jonathan Rosenbaum.)

In the diaries, Bogdanovich describes the bond with Welles as a “mutual love society.” He and Platt spent a lot of time with Welles and his partner, Oja Kodar (who was Croatian and with whom Bogdanovich spoke Serbo-Croatian). As Bogdanovich advanced in the business, Welles hoped that his young friend would make the necessary connections for him to make another film. Bogdanovich tried mightily; producers gamely entertained the notion before saying no. Instead, Bogdanovich became, for a while, Welles’s fixer, organizing his appearances on television talk shows, helping him produce and direct a TV special, writing furious responses to Charles Higham’s sharply negative biography of Welles and to a two-part essay published by Pauline Kael in The New Yorker, in 1971, which disputed Welles’s authorship of the script for “Citizen Kane.” When Welles managed to find financing for an independent film—one inspired, he said, by Bogdanovich’s tales of other veteran directors now out of work—he recruited Bogdanovich to act in it. The resulting film, “The Other Side of the Wind,” didn’t see the light of day until 2018, with Bogdanovich playing an integral role in its completion and eventual release. In return, Welles simply bestowed his brilliance upon Bogdanovich, both through grand reflections and through practical advice. He exhorted Bogdanovich to make “The Last Picture Show” in black-and-white: “ ‘Because every performance looks better in black and white!’ ” (The film’s success, and the success of its actors, proved his point.)

Bogdanovich’s bonding with his directorial heroes amounted to something like a film school for one. His lessons were unique tutorials, and his homework assignments are still being read today. In “But What I Really Want to Do Is Direct,” Bogdanovich details the joys and rigors of his self-generated cinematic education and, in the process, he crystallizes a method that more or less any young aspirant with talent and daring could follow. At the same time as the Method was taking hold among American actors, the auteur concept, advanced in the early fifties by young critics at Cahiers du Cinéma, was rising in France as a kind of Method for directing: instead of mastering specific techniques like a craftsperson, whether in film school or as an apprentice in the industry, these aspiring filmmakers were mastering the mind-sets of the directors they admired and connecting them with their own emotional lives and artistic inclinations. Bogdanovich was Hollywood’s first Method director. More than the techniques or styles of the great classic directors, he learned and imbibed their personalities, their sense of life. Where the figures of the French New Wave had only limited personal contact with the Hollywood artists they admired, Bogdanovich entered these icons’ worlds—and had their worlds enter him—both by way of the movies and by way of their personal influences and examples.

Bogdanovich’s case was special, and also offered a warning to his contemporaries. Though endowed with a sharp critical sensibility, he was never a working critic like his slightly older French counterparts. A working critic is forced into the now—not just the aesthetics of present-day filmmakers but also their confrontations with current crises, perspectives, and ways of life. When the New Wave critics became New Wave filmmakers, they continued to test past against present, making films that were of the moment. But Bogdanovich’s films were largely immured in the past—which, in a paradoxical way, made him an extreme, barely assimilable modernist, both in his commercial successes and his eventual failures. No less than with the frame-breaking extremes of French New Wave modernism, Bogdanovich gathered the forms and conventions of Hollywood classics and recombined them into a factitious realism. He studied his elders’ movies so closely and so extensively, and absorbed them so thoroughly, that they became the central realities of his life even though they were secondhand—not unlike an actor who plays a role so well and so completely that the only “he” left is the performance. Bogdanovich’s commercial successes were films that, along with their emotional immediacy, gratified a desire for movies and for the way movies had been. His diaries offer something of the same bittersweet double power, an irrepressible and incurable nostalgia to go with the energetic creation of a new movie world. When that new movie world definitively replaced the old one, in the mid-seventies, Bogdanovich’s troubles began. ♦

来源:纽约客中文网

本站旅行资讯与攻略整理自公开渠道及实地体验,仅代表作者个人观点,与本站立场无关。出行信息请以景区及相关部门最新公告为准。转载请保留原文链接并注明出处。
回顶部