
Chris Hodges is a real-estate agent in her fifties who lives with her husband in Madison, Georgia, a pretty little town fifty miles east of Atlanta. A vivacious and bespectacled Democrat, Hodges was, for most of her adult life, a news junkie. She watched “Morning Joe” on M.S.N.B.C., listened to National Public Radio all day, and read the New York Times and this magazine in between. She helped bring journalists of note to Madison’s cultural center, to speak about their work. One of her daughters studied journalism in college, and Hodges eagerly sought out internship opportunities and story ideas for her. Then, two years ago, Hodges began to give up. She traded the news for “true-crime B.S. and TikTok,” she told me recently. Why the change? “Apathy,” Hodges said. “Exhausted whiplash. Does anything I say or do really matter? The Earth is burning and no one cares.” The disconnect was personal, too: she did not consider herself to be an angry person, but she felt angry all the time—at Trump, mostly, but plenty of others in the news drew her ire. Hodges continued, wearily, “I just want to focus on the here and now with close friends and family, and up my mah-jongg game. So, basically: I’ve given up and I want to say, ‘I told ya so.’ ” A few weeks ago, on the night of the midterm elections, Hodges went to bed early. “I did not watch any of it,” she said. “I woke up to the blue bomb. I had all the e-mails and the texts. My friend’s, like, ‘Can you believe this?’ And I’m, like, ‘What fresh hell?’ ”
Hodges is one of a growing number of Americans who have decentered news from their lives. Benjamin Toff, the director of the journalism center at the University of Minnesota, has been studying news avoidance for ten years—essentially since the beginning of its interest to scholars—and, in 2024, he co-authored an award-winning book on the subject, “Avoiding the News: Reluctant Audiences for Journalism.” Toff told me recently that around forty-five per cent of Americans now say that they sometimes or often actively avoid the news, a number that has been steadily ticking up since the first Trump Administration. “There are a lot of different groups within that,” Toff explained. “The people doing it for wellness and mental-health reasons; the parents of young kids who feel like they don’t have time or want to avoid the doom and gloom at home; the political obsessives who feel addicted or angry when they tune in; conservative-news skeptics who are avoiding because they think it’s all lies.” (A related group sometimes gets included under the news-avoidance umbrella: people who—often as a result of low access, or because they live in news deserts, or simply from being focussed on trying to make ends meet—consume almost no news at all.)
Toff noted the results of a December survey conducted by the Pew Research Center, which suggested that wealthier and more educated people—especially liberal Democrats—felt more worn out by the amount of news compared with their less educated, less wealthy, and often more conservative counterparts. This isn’t entirely unexpected: supporters of the party out of power are typically more inclined to avoid news—the grim developments, as they see it, are relentless. “It would make a lot of sense to see somewhat less anxious liberal Democrats in these post-election weeks, as compared to conservative Republicans, who may be feeling a little more depressed about the state of the world,” Toff told me, noting that polling has yet to be done. “But the work I’ve been involved with over the years points to this being about a lot more than just politics.”
Sometimes people want to cut down on their exposure to technology as much as to news. “People’s sense of their relationship with news is intertwined with how they feel about their mobile devices and about the digital platforms,” Toff explained. “It can be hard to disentangle what is actually about the news versus the ways in which people are accessing and encountering news these days.” There is evidence that people are noticing the absence of what Toff described to me as a “contained ritual of experience”—a print magazine or paper, a TV program, a book club—“which I think makes it easier to process that information and go about your life without feeling the weight of the world constantly bearing down on you.”
“What people are expressing in the polling data is a sense of fatigue and frustration about news,” Toff told me. “That doesn’t mean they are avoiding it entirely.” Over all, levels of news consumption still tend to be highly correlated with socioeconomic status. Many people actually become, in effect, consumers of “secondhand news” who don’t always know where they heard something newsy. They may skim, pause, unsubscribe, and otherwise dip in and out of the frothing news current. Carl Seville, the owner of a construction-consulting firm in Atlanta, told me recently that he deleted his Times app around Trump’s second Inauguration. He also stopped listening to N.P.R. every day. Now, he told me, he gets “a few bits of news from Facebook and LinkedIn.” He’ll also check out The Atlantic. “But I don’t read, watch, or listen to any daily news anymore.” Seville calls his new approach a “news diet,” a newish entry in the news-consumption lexicon which is receiving more widespread usage. Katherine McClure, an artist, who also lives in Atlanta, told me that she’s on a news diet, too. “There’s only so much stress a person can handle, and the very sight of the President adds an unnecessary level of stress,” McClure said. “Because there is nothing I can do about anything he does.”
It was not hard to find news avoiders and dieters in my own circles. A friend of mine—a graduate of a top university, well read, working in film—was shocked not long ago when I mentioned to him that the Georgia senator Jon Ossoff, who attended our small Atlanta high school, was among the leading contenders to become the Democratic Presidential nominee in 2028. “Makes me too stressed out and got too much on the platter these days,” he replied, when I asked him about his news consumption. Christina Tretter-Herriger, a real-estate attorney in Buffalo, New York, invoked a magazine cover published in early 2024. “The crystallizing moment for me was when The Atlantic did an issue asking the question, ‘What if he wins again?’ ” she said. “It was at that point that I realized I was already on the ledge, dialled up to level eleven. I have no more levels.” A French teacher in north Florida named Marilyn Hall made it about a year into Trump’s second term before turning her news spigot down to a relative drip. “I stopped watching the news, because I couldn’t tolerate the suffering in Trump America,” Hall said. “I usually walk out of the room when my husband has the news on, which is very often. My despair has become so severe that my family doesn’t like listening to me—and we’re all on the same side politically!”
Kevin Liles, a commercial photographer in Atlanta who sometimes shoots for newspapers and magazines, had his own realization just a few months ago. A Times headline popped up while he was watching his daughter play in their front yard. “There was nothing particular about the news that day,” Liles told me. “It was just the accumulation of just headline after headline—just, like, doomsday. And it’s been that way. Every headline I would scroll, I was just honestly trying to see: is there anything positive in here that would be uplifting? And everything is just, like, Iran’s blowing up, the President’s doing this or that. Blah, blah, blah. And I look over at my daughter, who’s climbing a tree, and I’m, like, ‘Man, I cannot do this.’ ” He went on, “I know all of this is real and it’s happening, but it is not affecting what’s happening right here right now with her.”
It’s not just Democrats who are cutting back on news. I met Brady Day in the summer of 2021, in Dalton, Georgia, at a campaign event for Marjorie Taylor Greene; Day was outside the convention center at a merch table. He wore a “2A” hat and a T-shirt that read: “SAVE AMERICA, STOP SOCIALISM.” I’d shown up with Marcus Flowers, a Democrat running against Greene, whom Day recognized from the news. Flowers agreed to a photo with the young Republican. Afterward, Day photoshopped an “I’M TEAM GREENE” banner onto the image and made it his Facebook profile picture. “I was proud of that,” Day told me recently. At the time, he was a rabid consumer of online and TV news, frequently checking his phone to see what Trump or Greene or Tucker Carlson had said, or “whatever ridiculous thing the Democrats were doing.” About a year ago, when Trump went after Congressman Thomas Massie and also attacked Greene—calling her a “traitor” and leading to her exile from politics—Day, who is now twenty-four and working as an industrial electrician, began to avoid the news, too.
“Now I’m completely disconnected,” Day told me. “I’ll read a headline if I see it, but I don’t go out of my way to look at the news like I used to.” He added, “It’s not that I don’t care. It’s just that it’s disappointing when you see stuff that’s going on.” He’s changed his profile picture from the image of him and Flowers outside the Greene event to one of him and his fiancée posing sweetly on a sand dune.
On the supply side of the news economy, some are trying to make the product inspire less fear and loathing—and even become enjoyable again. In early October, in Boise, the American Press Institute held a local news summit on news avoidance and digital wellness. A.P.I. is a nonprofit dedicated to helping local media survive and thrive. The event’s goal was to figure out ways for local news outlets to help Americans build healthy relationships with civic information. Many of the most creative attempts at doing so are taking place at the local level, A.P.I.’s senior vice-president, Samantha Ragland, told me. These include so-called article clubs, subscriber dinners, and community-news cafés, all of which aim to create offline experiences, expand reader agency, and increase “joyful and thoughtful connection.”
Among the summit’s attendees was Jake Hylton, the executive director of LOOKOUT News, a nonprofit newsroom in Phoenix dedicated to, as Hylton puts it, “hard-hitting local queer journalism.” When LOOKOUT began as a Substack four years ago, Hylton and his partner surveyed the L.G.B.T.Q.+ community in Arizona. “They felt like they weren’t being represented correctly in legacy media outside of the drag shows, the Pride parades, or whatever Kari Lake said,” Hylton told me, referring to the failed MAGA candidate for an Arizona U.S. Senate seat, who has called gender-affirming care “evil.” He went on, “The Arizona Republic was publishing more op-eds about pronouns than actual coverage of trans bills in the state legislature. All these readers really ever saw was their community members dead or hurting in a big news story, being used as a means of clicks.”
In sum, the news was, to Hylton’s respondents, “a little poisonous,” he told me. “The way that we decided to inoculate that poison is with community,” he said. “That word is thrown around a lot, but the trust that you build with communities is the best way out of this news-avoidance spiral.” LOOKOUT is now a multistate operation with four full-time staffers and a pool of eighteen freelancers, which produces three newsletters a week, a quarterly print news magazine “with a zine-like feel,” and three to four dozen community events a year. The vast majority of LOOKOUT’s stories—recent in-depth pieces have covered transgender medical care in ICE detention and a gay Republican election denier who is running for office in Phoenix—originate from conversations with community members, often at LOOKOUT meetups that are not explicitly news-related.
“We were just bullshitting and somebody was, like, ‘I didn’t recognize that I could literally just tell people that we’d be playing a movie in a park and we’ll bring the movie and the hot cocoa and they bring the blankets,’ ” Hylton said. Similarly, LOOKOUT’s big annual fund-raiser isn’t a gala; it’s a dance party. “Our events always harken back to L.G.B.T.Q. culture and history, so disco and house music,” Hylton said of the gala’s playlist. “Events don’t have to be expensive and elaborate. Just show up as a human being.” People have asked Hylton to quantify the return on investment for these gatherings. “The response that first came out of my mouth was ‘What’s the R.O.I. on human connection? Is that the question you’re asking?’ Building connection and human relationships is the foundation of a strong business. An audience isn’t an A.T.M.”
The outlet now has around sixteen thousand unique readers, one of whom is a Sarah Oglesby-Dunegan, a fifty-four-year-old Unitarian Universalist minister in Chandler, Arizona. “Our theology is about pluralism and creating community and that’s very much the way that they have approached their media,” Dunegan told me, of LOOKOUT. “Reaching the margins and helping people feel like you belong and you are important. When you see news stories about yourself and the things that you’re struggling with, you begin to feel seen.” Dunegan has pared down her own news intake in recent years: she doesn’t read HuffPost or listen to “The Daily” like she used to. “My limbic system feels like it’s recovering,” she said. “LOOKOUT has helped with that.” She went on, “Originally, I read them because they cover L.G.B.T.Q issues—I have a trans kid—but I’ve been really pleasantly surprised by how many articles are on other things I care about.”
Block Club Chicago is a nonprofit newsroom with an even larger reach than LOOKOUT’s. The Midwestern outlet’s launch, in 2018, was funded through a Kickstarter campaign, and it has since grown to employ forty full-time staffers, with an audience of around a million unique monthly visitors; twenty thousand of these are paying subscribers. Block Club’s beats are organized according to Chicago neighborhoods: each one has its own reporters, who generally live within its boundaries and produce a neighborhood newsletter; a small investigative team, called the Watch, roams around assisting these reporters with ambitious projects. One Block Club investigation, from 2023, looked into the landlords of mismanaged properties and vacant lots on the South Side, which the owners had parlayed into Maseratis and luxury condos for themselves. Another deep dive, which reporters began working on early in the pandemic, broke the news that a West Side hospital was rerouting its first vaccine deliveries to the wealthy friends of facility executives. In messages obtained by the site, the C.O.O. bragged about vaccinating Eric Trump.
Block Club has also found ways to make stories palatable to different audiences at once. When the outlet covered the police shooting of thirteen-year-old Adam Toledo, in early 2021, on Chicago’s West Side, they grappled with how to incorporate the body-camera footage into the story. “It called into question the official narrative,” Lizzie Schiffman Tufano, the nonprofit’s vice-president of revenue, and a former Chicago Sun-Times staffer, told me. “So it seemed inarguable that it would be at the very top of our coverage. But we also knew it would distress some people to watch it. We said, ‘Why not make two versions?’ ” Block Club decided to share its two stories as a unit everywhere: one with the body-camera video and one that just describes it. Tufano went on, “We talk a lot internally about how we show up for our audience and engage with them and treat them—and we come back often to just the idea of care.”
To this end, the organization also tries to emotionally balance the heavy stuff with lighter news. “I’m able to write about city policies or long-standing historical problems, say, on the South Side of Chicago,” Atavia Reed, a Block Club reporter from that area of the city, told me. “And then I can say, ‘This person has jumping worms in their garden. What does that even mean?’ Or, ‘Who is the watermelon man that’s always on a certain corner selling fruit?’ Being here in neighborhoods is not just dropping in. We know it so well because we’ve lived it.” When neighborhood reporters like Reed send out their weekly neighborhood newsletters, they often include details about their pets and weekend plans, Tufano told me. “We share whatever news is most relevant, but we’re mindful of the over-all experience.” A popular series this year followed a Girl Scout troop trying to meet a cookie-selling goal. “When we covered it, they more than octupled their goal,” Tufano said.
Tufano thinks of these stories as “palate cleansers.” Perhaps the outlet’s best-known palate-cleansing series covers a rodent-shaped impression that, for decades, could be seen in the cement sidewalk of the Roscoe Village neighborhood. Most people saw the outlines of a rat. A couple years ago, when someone filled the hole with plaster, other residents dug it back out. The city removed the entire slab in the spring of 2024, after crowds of self-described pilgrims became a regular nuisance: there was a wedding on site, as well as a shrine to what some had dubbed “Splatatouille.” “I’m glad that it has brought people joy,” one neighbor of the rat-shaped hole wrote, according to one Block Club piece on the phenomenon. “But we need you all to chill out. Please.”
The section of sidewalk was preserved and moved to Chicago’s City Hall, where it has been on display, and it has its own Wikipedia entry. But the coverage keeps coming. “We did a story yesterday on the rat hole,” Tufano told me. “They had it on display at the Smashing Pumpkins show in Chicago this week.” The nineties alt-rock band had come to town as part of its “Rats in a Cage” tour. (In a story titled “Rat Hole in a Cage,” Block Club’s reporter quoted a spokesperson for the city of Chicago explaining that the slab is generally not loaned out, but this opportunity “was almost too perfect.”) Block Club sells T-shirts with the rat hole on them, alongside other “Natural Wonders of Chicago,” including “Chance the Snapper,” an alligator that somehow ended up, for a time, in the lagoon at Humboldt Park, and a giant turtle nicknamed Chonk.
Jeremiah Wallace, a twenty-five-year-old voting-rights organizer from the South Side, told me that he followed the rat-hole saga. Block Club is his No. 1 news source these days. “With the political state of the world right now, and this country specifically, there’s a lot of stories and news that bring people down,” Wallace said. “So it’s important to have something that we can laugh at and learn from that’s about the city where we live.”
Still, even fun news has a way of taking a turn. Tufano told me, “People were very upset when we reported”—after the Times had broken the news—“that it was technically possibly a squirrel, not a rat, that had created that hole.” She sighed. “Journalism doesn’t always have a satisfying conclusion.”
Meanwhile, in Madison, Georgia, Chris Hodges, the real-estate agent, began dipping her toes back into the news following the midterms. “I do want to watch it from the historical perspective,” she told me recently. “I’ve never experienced anything like this before, ever.” But she does not think she’ll return to her peak consumption levels. “It’ll probably be more like with Obama where you kind of just trusted that everything was going to be O.K.,” Hodges said. “You had faith in the country.” ♦
来源:纽约客中文网