
In his new book, “The President Deserves Better: Leadership and Accountability to Keep America Great,” John Ullyot argues that President Donald Trump’s advisers and appointees have let him down in his faltering second term. As Ullyot, a former deputy assistant to Trump at the White House who has held several government jobs during Trump’s Administrations, including as chief spokesman for the National Security Council, writes “The bottom line is this: The President deserves better.” He adds, “And it’s not just from his Cabinet Secretaries. Many individuals and groups work behind the scenes to block or slow-roll Trump’s reform agenda. You often hear about how liberal media outlets and the foot-dragging, antireform, bureaucratic Deep State try to stop Trump. This book provides a first-hand account of how that happens on a day-to-day basis.”
Recently, in The Atlantic, Ullyot called for the resignation of Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, whom he had advised at the Pentagon in 2025, saying that Hegseth had mismanaged the Iran war and was becoming an embarrassment to the President. (In April of that year, Ullyot detailed the chaos at the Pentagon under Hegseth in Politico.) I recently spoke by phone with Ullyot about his time working with Trump, and the source of the problems in the President’s Administration. Our conversation, edited for length and clarity, is below.
I read your Atlantic piece calling for Hegseth’s resignation. What is it that you think he has done wrong?
Hegseth has done a lot of damage to the Pentagon and to the military. I volunteered to stand up his press operation just for a short period of time at the start of his term last year, and he and I got along very well. When I left, as planned, after standing up his operation and turning it over to his friend—a friend of his that he had selected to run the operation—he thanked me for doing a good job, et cetera. And then it was after that that things got very crazy. I didn’t notice a lot of crazy things going on when I was there, but it was after that point, after I left, that I decided to write that op-ed in Politico. And that was because things had gotten so crazy that he had two of my friends marched out of the building by security, and he accused them of leaking material to the press, and he just had become very paranoid about the leaks.
Hegseth is the least qualified and most polarizing Defense Secretary in modern memory. And as a Marine veteran, and as someone who has spent a lot of time in both the Senate Armed Services Committee and at the National Security Council working with senior members of the military and senior Pentagon leaders, I felt the need to speak out, because he was doing real damage and it was hurting the President as well.
He was appointed to the job by President Trump, right?
Yes.
So how do you understand President Trump’s decision to appoint him, and also to keep him in the job, even as he’s doing this tremendous damage that you referenced?
So, the President hired him. In his first term, President Trump hired people based on recommendations from many people who were outsiders. And he felt, I believe, that he was not well served by several of them. In his second term, it has been different. He’s hired more on loyalty and hired more people who are going to pursue his agenda rather than those who have a résumé.
So is Hegseth pursuing Trump’s agenda?
I think he is in a lot of ways. The President decided to go to war in Iran, and the Secretary reportedly pushed him into that. I do not think that the President has paid attention to the damage that Hegseth has done on either the cultural front or the self-promoting front, or to the damage that he’s done in taking out very good leaders of the military. I think that the President is mainly briefed on what’s going on at the Pentagon by Pete Hegseth, and doesn’t have people around him who have apprised him of the job that Hegseth’s doing and the damage that he’s done.
If Trump could focus a little more, sit down, read a briefing book on what Hegseth was doing, it might be easier to get him to come around to what you’re saying.
Yeah, I think that’s right. But I really do think that the President hired Hegseth without really looking under the hood. He watches Fox News a lot, and Hegseth, he’s very bombastic, outspoken; he really shouts into the camera on Fox News. And I think President Trump said, “Hey, this guy must be a real military hero. He’s a man’s man, et cetera.” I doubt that he looked at his résumé much, because a lot of people are surprised that Hegseth was not a SEAL Team Six door-kicker or something like that. But he has a persona, and he wrote three books about lethality in the military. I read all three of them before going to work for him.
Oh, wow.
Yeah, and basically they all say the same thing, and they can be summed up with one page: The military’s gone woke. And, No beardos, no weirdos, no trannies, no fatties, this type of thing.
Did that message appeal to you when you first joined the Administration, but then you thought, Oh, maybe the “no beardos, no weirdos” thing is not actually the way to carry out the running of the Pentagon?
I wrote an op-ed back when Hegseth was still in high school, when I left the Marine Corps, about the need to keep high physical standards, because that was going out, particularly with integrating women into Marine units. Anyway, so I’m not agreeing with him. He’s not the person who invented the idea of high physical standards. And then, in terms of his criticism of how identity politics were woven into the military, I agreed with that. But I wouldn’t make it a big deal. I would just get it done. So I didn’t think you needed to beat your chest about restoring . . . whether it’s in any government position, I agree with eliminating identity politics or identity-based hiring. So I was on board with both of those, but I wasn’t screaming about it.
“Talk softly and carry a big stick” kind of thing.
Yeah, just make the changes and don’t make a big deal about it.
It does occur to me that people who write books that, as you say, can be summarized by lines like “No beardos, no weirdos” might not be so laser-focussed on really running the department as well as they should, and might be more focussed on being obnoxious and things like that. I don’t know. I’m just speculating.
Yeah, I think that’s right. I mean, with his résumé and his bombast, I think that he was probably qualified to be the Pentagon spokesperson, or since he spends a lot of time P.T.ing with the troops, he could have been head of the Presidential physical-fitness council, like Arnold Schwarzenegger was. But, actually, you need a manager or somebody with real management experience to run the largest department in the federal government.
Let’s just go back to President Trump, because your book is very interesting on this idea that Trump has been let down by the people around him in his second term. Is the problem Hegseth, or is the problem more that Trump didn’t do his due diligence?
I don’t think he did due diligence. I think President Trump just saw him on Fox News, liked what he saw, and didn’t say, O.K., let’s look into his background.
Is that then the fault of people around Trump, or is it more Trump’s fault? Because your book is saying that Trump himself is a very effective leader, but that he’s been let down. So I’m curious how you think that through.
So I think that ultimately the buck stops with the President. So, when I say the President deserves better, yes, he deserves better from his staff, but above all he deserves better from himself. Let’s say you’re a friend of a pro golfer and the pro golfer knows that he can do better. You would say, “Hey, look, I think you deserve better than that. You deserve to train a little more or to work on your swing with a swing coach,” et cetera. It’s not a great analogy.
No.
Like any C.E.O., the President is the steward of his own brand. And his brand has slipped badly. But he needs to have staff that are not yes-men. He never did this in the first term, but if you look at these scripted or televised Cabinet meetings where they’ll go on for an hour, the Cabinet meetings with the cameras rolling, they’ll just go around while all the Cabinet members are trying to outdo each other. Each Cabinet member’s trying to outdo the others in praising the President. And that’s not serious. The President doesn’t need that, but ultimately he’s responsible.
Trump’s first Cabinet meeting, in 2017, five months into his term, included a lot of praise, if I remember correctly.
Well, I mean, that could have been the case, but now every Cabinet meeting is televised. I mean, in the first term there were some serious people there who were supporters of the President, but they were not seal clappers the way you see a lot in this Administration.
I am looking now, and in June of 2017, at that first Cabinet meeting, they did go around the room praising him. But, as you say, there’s going around the room and praising him, and then there’s going around the room and really praising him. So you have to draw distinctions, which I think is what you are trying to do.
That’s right. I’ve been in and out of the private sector and advise C.E.O.s, and I say a good C.E.O. surrounds himself with people who are strong enough to tell him what he doesn’t want to hear. And one of them that I worked with was Alan Mulally, when he was C.E.O. of Ford, and they were doing the auto-bailout hearings, back in December of 2008. Mulally was great to work with, and, famously, when he took over Ford, he had his first review of the business units and all the charts, and he said, “Put a green, yellow, or red chart based on how your business unit is doing.” So it was all green while the company was losing billions. And then one executive finally put up a red slide, and Mulally just started applauding him, and later that executive became C.E.O. and replaced Mulally. Mulally wanted to hear the bad news, probably before the good news.
Does it seem to you that Trump wants to hear the bad news before the good news?
No, I don’t think so. I think he deserves better from himself on that. He deserves to look under the hood much more than he has been doing in his second term.
Your book is about how the President deserves better from his staff, but it seems like one of the things you’re saying in this conversation is that the President deserves better from himself, which is a little different.
Yes, that’s right. He made three promises when I worked for him as a senior adviser on the 2016 campaign: no more forever wars, drain the swamp, and put America first. In his first term, when I worked for him in the White House, he was new to Washington and very laser-focussed on delivering on those priorities.
When I remember the first term, it was a lot of tweeting in the middle of the night. It was a lot of staying in the residence to watch Fox News. It was a lot of golfing. I’m not saying things are exactly the same as this term, but when you say the President was laser-focussed on his priorities, I’m trying to remember that.
No, you’re right about his tweeting and his watching TV and staying up late. That hasn’t changed, but what I think has changed in this second term is that he has lost focus on implementing his promises.
I think the ballroom is distracting him. Honestly, I think that’s one of the problems.
Yeah, exactly. So, anyway, things slipped in the second term. Now you’ve got former aides who are cashing in on his name.
Is he cashing in, too, do we think?
I don’t think he is, but certainly there are allegations that his family is. I mean, I think that he’s not personally—
Oh, so you think it’s more his family than him?
Well, it’s his family, but it’s also, let’s look at the ballroom or the library. He is building these big projects that need a lot of money, and so any donor to any President does not contribute to their projects five years after they’ve been President. They’re all lining up to contribute when the President has the power. But, in draining the swamp, that was his promise to be a different President, and now you’ve got his aides.
But do you think that flows from the top? Maybe this gets back to what you say about the fact that he himself deserves better. Maybe he should tell himself to tell his family not to focus on business deals.
Right. This was not a visible embarrassment in the first term. Now it’s a visible embarrassment, and, in fact, he’s reportedly surprised by some of these revelations. So, when we come back to “the President deserves better,” he should have set the tone in the second term and said, “No more of this B.S., I’m different. That’s why I was elected in 2016, because people wanted me to drain the swamp, and I don’t want to have anybody, whether it’s my family or anybody else, riding on my name.”
I think one important thing about your book is getting the message out there that he needs to do this.
Yeah. I appreciate that. That’s what I was trying to do in writing the book. And I had no idea when I started writing it a year and a half ago that the Republican Party would take the shellacking that it did. I mean, nine Senate seats. I worked in the Senate for seven years, and nine seats is seventeen per cent of all the senators. I looked it up—seventeen per cent of the entire collection of senators in the chamber.
Wouldn’t nine Senate seats be nine per cent of the Senate?
Of the Republicans. Republicans had fifty-three. If you divide nine out of fifty-three—
Of course, yeah, my mistake.
Yeah, no worries. So, anyway, nine seats is a lot of seats. Anyway, when I started writing this book, I was saying it is maybe intended for future Presidents, but now it has become a lot more relevant to this President.
Well, honestly, if there’s a theme to this conversation, I think it’s that if Trump had read Hegseth’s books, or if he reads your book now, things could be better. Maybe Trump reading more books is the solution here.
Yeah, maybe that’s the solution.
Last question for you: What if someone said, “Look, this Donald Trump, he’s got a little older, he’s surrounded by more loyalists, but fundamentally, this is the guy who, from the start, talked about Obama’s birth certificate, and then he talked about ‘Mexican’ judges, and then he insulted people all the time, and there are all these accusations about how he assaults women, and then there were all these things that he said about Haitians, and January 6th, and then you go to the second term, and he’s posting the video of the Obamas as apes, and actually he is just the same guy who never really had any sense of how to run the country or a sense of the national interest”? I’m not saying there’s any merit to this idea, but what do you think of it?
Well, no, I think that’s a very good point. What I would say is he’s the same man, but, politically, voters were once willing to overlook this pugilistic, crude character tweeting about the Obamas as apes and all of that business.
It seems as if you wish Trump would remind himself, and remind people, that fundamentally he was a businessman who came to shake up Washington. If he could get back to that, maybe he could get back on the right track.
Yeah, absolutely. There’s still a runway for him to get things done. ♦
来源:纽约客中文网